Home  Products  Reviews  About  Contact 


The Lion in Winter
Average Rating: 4.5     Total Reviews: 187
More Information

The Lion in Winter     On: 2008-05-12

This is one of the best movies made! As close to Shakespeare as you can get in modern times. The dialogue is incredible,especially in the interaction of Hepburn and OToole. They also seem to be having such a good time with it.The whole cast couldnt have been chosen more perfectly.The tension between the brothers as they back stab at the machinations of their parents is palatable.For lovers of historical drama this is a must. For lovers of great dialogue and charisma between actors this is a must. For lovers of great film making in general this is a must!
A stunning portrayal of greed and corruption, and the price we pay for power...     On: 2008-05-01

Katherine Hepburn is considered one of the greatest actresses to ever grace the big screen. In fact, many of her devoted fans have coined the nickname `Kate the Great when referencing this cinematic icon. In this day and age of modern cinema being compared to this legend is one of the highest compliments any actress can hope to receive. Sadly, I have not seen many of Hepburns films and so I am really in the dark as to the extent of her talent. But last night I sat down to watch `The Lion in Winter, a film I had heard much about but knew very little of. I am now convinced, from just this single performance, that all the praise and admiration is justly deserved (as was that Oscar win).

With quick wit and a masterfully dead-panned delivery, Katherine Hepburn scorches the screen as Queen Eleanor of Aquitaine, the Achilles-Heel to her husband King Henry II. Eleanor and Henry do not have the happiest marriage, Henry keeping Eleanor locked away for the majority of the year because of her rebellion against him. He allows her to visit for the Christmas holiday and it is during this visit that tension abounds, tension that leads to betrayal and a total collapse of family. While Eleanor is visiting she rallies behind their eldest son Richard for his right to the throne, but Henry is determined to make his youngest son John the next King. Left in the middle is Geoffrey, perhaps the most cunning of all, who devises a way of secluding the throne for himself.

Adding to the internal tension within the family ranks is the pressure being put upon King Henry by King Philip of France to give his sister Alais hand to Richard in marriage. King Philip is a young King, but a crafty one and soon he is finding ways to destroy King Henrys rule from within his own castle walls.

The acting, for the most part, is flawless. Ive already mentioned my adoration of Katherine Hepburns marvelous performance, but much must be said for Peter OToole as well. Its still so shocking to me that he has yet to win an acting Oscar. The Academy must feel really stupid right about now. His fiery delivery as King Henry is brilliant to witness. Anthony Hopkins, who makes his big screen debut here, is also a marvel to watch. Its apparent from this early performance that he would one day become one of our greatest working actors. His portrayal of the determined yet haunted Richard shows control and maturity beyond his experience. Timothy Dalton also delivers a fine debut performance as King Philip, infusing enough charisma to make his cunning all the more believable. Jane Merrow is sympathetic as Alais and John Castle is phenomenal as Geoffrey. I was astounded by the depth he brought to his character, making him the most fascinating character in my humble opinion. In fact, the acting in this film is so masterful that I am pained to have to single out Nigel Terry as the biggest drawback to an otherwise brilliant film. His portrayal of John is excruciating to watch. Instead of making John a believable buffoon he creates a campy feel that takes away from the impact of the film. Thankfully the rest of the cast is so brilliant that they make up for his lack of impression.

I will add as a side note that I find it ironic how, while watching this movie, I couldnt help but draw comparisons to the marvelous Glenn Close when watching Hepburn, noticing how their acting style, even their facial features are very similar. I say this is ironic because come to find out, Close also took on the role of Queen Eleanor in the TV adaptation of `The Lion in Winter.

Small world.

Much has been said of the Oscar winning script by James Goldman (adapted from his stage play) and much should be said. The dialog is tight and witty and, while the film is a tad wordy, it flows beautifully, remaining fresh and natural throughout. Anthony Harvey directs the film with conviction and dedication, and it shows. From the opening credits to the final frame he beautifully captures the mood presented by the subject.

`The Lion in Winter is a stunning portrayal of the power of greed and the danger of power. Watching this dysfunctional family crumble at its very foundation is unsettling yet captivating. The film does to a degree feel dated; you cant escape that. The sets and costumes and whatnot are not as fresh and vibrant as one would witness in modern cinema (the recent `The Other Boleyn Girl is a marvelous example of how orgasmic these modern period films can look) but what doesnt feel dated is the marvelous performances and the smartly written and intricately woven script.

`The Lion in Winter is a brilliant testament to the fact that no matter when a film was made, if it was made right it will stand the test of time.
Deeply moving.     On: 2008-04-26

The Lion in Winter is a breath of fresh air. I just happened to come across this classic film on t.v. one night and boy this movie is a masterpiece. Katharine Hepburn and Peter OToole are flawless! Their acting abilities are top-notch, no wonder critics swoon over both these talented thespians. I highly recommend this medieval treasure, enjoy!
The Lion In Winter     On: 2008-03-30

Its wonderful to watch great actors and a great movie. The Lion in Winter is definite addition to my video library; one to watch over and over.
LION IN WINTER-Great Cast, Story, a Magical FIlm Experience     On: 2008-03-11

I never saw this great unconditional 5 star film when it first came out in 1968. In fact, I didnt even know of its existence until late in 1977 when a friend who is a professional film editor and collector brought a 16 mm print to my home in Connecticut and gave me a private screening.

We saw this film in the late evening and the magic of that night and the performances of the great cast were something to be remembered. The cast included the one and only Peter OToole, the great Katharine Hepburn, as well as Sir Anthony Hopkins, and Timothy Dalton. The musical score was also grand and beautiful and helped to establish the wonderful period mood.
Astonishing
by: katknit    On: 2008-01-22

They dont make em like this anymore. Great cast, great screenplay, great characters, great story. How amazing to see a young Anthony Hopkins, way before he became the star he is today. Timothy Dalton must have peaked early, in his portrayal of King Philippe at the beginning of his reign. Hepburn and OToole, those giants of the acting world, play off each other with panache, vacillating between restraint and excess, love and hate. The sets are accurate and visually compelling (its eye-opening to see kings and queens in the bleakness of the 1183 castle setting).
This movie positively crackles with passion, ambition, fear, and desire. Truly a tour de force, worth every Oscar.
Movie classic     On: 2008-01-20

I watched this again recently. What a classic! Riveting performances by OToole & Hepburn which capture the essence of Henry 11 and his times. Very difficult to fault in any way. Even the depiction of Chinon is remarkably accurate as far as I could tell & I know the place well.
A Great, Old Classic     On: 2008-01-15

A great old movie that is surprisingly historically accurate. It was great seeing all these excellent actors and a young Timothy Dalton.
How, from where we started, did we ever reach this Christmas?     On: 2007-10-23

Anyone who is bored by this film should be hung from a gibbet until the crows pluck out their eyes. It is one helluva viewing, especially before a live audience. My only complaint: why the devil didnt they do a 5.1 mix on this thing when they were restoring it a couple of years ago?? I saw it at the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences and the film preservationist proudly announced that, during sound restoration, they decided to remain true to the original mono mix rather do a stereo pass. Cricket. Cricket. Only a fool or two applauded. You cant have John Barrys Oscar-winning score in skull-splitting mono. It doesnt take much these days, thanks to the democracy of digital, to do a remix. Give me the elements and a ProTools and Ill do it.

Enough. Its still the greatest Medieval drama ever made, and corrects all the silliness of "Becket." Nobody does Christmas like the Plantagenets!
The Lion in Winter     On: 2007-10-20

Katherine Hepburn won an Oscar for her performance in this movie, and its easy to see why she was the winner. The is still a classic, and I highly recommend it for plot development and quality of performance.
Truly a masterpiece ; Must buy "Becket" too!     On: 2007-09-20

I am a big Peter OToole fan and this move is incredible. The performances by Peter, Kathryn Hepburn, Anthony Hopkins, and Timothy Dalton are powerful, yet not over the top.

Also, make sure to purchase "Becket" (OToole plays the same character, King Henry II). He teams up with Richard Burton and they both do not disappoint!

Becket
"Every family has its ups and downs"     On: 2007-09-09

This is one of the witty lines Katherine Hepburn delivers, as shes lying on the ground after one of the many long, dragged out battles with someone...cant remember who. They all hated each other so after a while I lost track.

I thoroughly applaud the brilliant acting, the smart script, great photography and even some lovely music. However, watching and listening to three hours of family members scheming and screaming just made me tired. Maybe it was only two hours but it seemed like much much longer. Tacking a "happy ending" on after all the psychic bloodshed was really ridiculous.

If this is your cup o tea, then enjoy! Frankly,I can think of much better uses for this great cast.


"Every family has its ups and downs"     On: 2007-09-08

This is one of the witty lines Katherine Hepburn delivers, as shes lying on the ground after one of the many long, dragged out battles with someone...cant remember who. They all hated each other so after a while I lost track.

I thoroughly applaud the brilliant acting, the smart script, great photography and even some lovely music. However, watching and listening to three hours of family members scheming and screaming just made me tired. Maybe it was only two hours but it seemed like much much longer. Tacking a "happy ending" on after all the psychic bloodshed was really ridiculous.

If this is your cup o tea, then enjoy! Frankly,I can think of much better uses for this great cast.


Envy all who get to watch it for the first time...     On: 2007-08-30

The Lion in Winter is one of those movies where points of plot and dialogue make you swing your head wildly to the person next to you in compulsive `did you see/hear that, `wasnt that great? glee. Out of consideration, may want to watch it alone.

And it deserves ceremony. I tell friends to play it on a stormy night, get under the blanket, have some hearty soup with some suitably chunky, unrefined bread... and enjoy.

At one point OToole, torn between loyalty and selfishness throws his arms out in surrender to the night and says "the sky is pocked with stars". Rewind, play again, swing head wildly.

The Royal Dysfunctional Family and the Height of Entertainment     On: 2007-08-22

This is an unbelievably well acted movie with Katharine Hepburn and Peter OToole, whose characters are Eleanor of Aquitaine and Henry II, King of England. Included in this cast is Anthony Hopkins as an uncrowned Richard the Lion-Heart, and Timothy Dalton as King Philip II of France, and Nigel Terry as the ambitious but foolish Prince John. With the addition of the Geoffrey Duke of Brittany played by John Castle the group set themselves against one another seeking to manipulate and use whatever political means available to secure the throne of England when Henry II, finally falls. Each character is antagonistic towards the other and will stop at nothing at receiving the coveted prize.

Their hatred for one another is expressed in their endless plotting and continuous insulting of one another through witty sarcasm, and venomous spewing. The dialogue is truly what makes this drama entertaining, coupled with the each characters attempt to dominate the other through secrecy and political intrigue. In their desire for blood, the pain of each character emerges through their acknowledgement of such, which has fueled the hatred which has embittered their lives. The cast truly engages with one another which truly engages us. It is both a riveting story and an interesting piece of historical fiction.

Note: The Lion in Winter has inspired many to discover more about Eleanor of Aquitaine (myself included). She was a woman who was a legend in her own time so much so that history has always referenced her to being of homeland, Aquitaine, rather than the Queen of England or France, both of which were titles she possessed in her lifetime.

Katherine Hepburn and Peter O'Toole sizzle in this fiery production.....
by: mariposarosa2    On: 2007-08-22

THE LION IN WINTER succeeds on so many levels as a wonderful example of historically-inspired filmmaking, at its best. For starters, the casting is impeccable, with Katherine Hepburn as Eleanor of Aquitane and Peter OToole as Henry the II. The estranged couple only reunites during one fateful Christmas season, where the two must decide how to divide the inheritance amongst their sons. Their scheming eldest child, Richard the Lionhearted (Anthony Hopkins), is devious, duplicitous and deceitful and butts heads with Philip of France (Timothy Dalton) whose goal is to ultimately destroy the kingdom and take everything for himself. Secondly, this gives you a taste of English history and insight into how turbulent the monarchy has ALWAYS been. Eons before Prince Charles and Princess Diana, there was Queen Eleanor and King Henry. The lively scenes are brilliantly directed and Katherine Hepburn won a well-deserved Academy Award for Best Actress in this wonderful film. Dont miss out on this one.
Katharine Hepburn and Peter O'Toole sizzle in this fiery production.....
by: mariposarosa2    On: 2007-08-22

THE LION IN WINTER succeeds on so many levels as a wonderful example of historically-inspired filmmaking, at its best. For starters, the casting is impeccable, with Katharine Hepburn as Eleanor of Aquitane and Peter OToole as Henry the II. The estranged couple only reunites during one fateful Christmas season, where the two must decide how to divide the inheritance amongst their sons. Their scheming eldest child, Richard the Lionhearted (Anthony Hopkins), is devious, duplicitous and deceitful and butts heads with Philip of France (Timothy Dalton) whose goal is to ultimately destroy the kingdom and take everything for himself. Secondly, this gives you a taste of English history and insight into how turbulent the monarchy has ALWAYS been. Eons before Prince Charles and Princess Diana, there was Queen Eleanor and King Henry. The lively scenes are brilliantly directed and Katharine Hepburn won a well-deserved Academy Award for Best Actress in this wonderful film. Dont miss out on this one.
Katharine Hepburn and Peter O'Toole sizzle in this fiery production.....
by: mariposarosa2    On: 2007-08-21

THE LION IN WINTER succeeds on so many levels as a wonderful example of historically-inspired filmmaking, at its best. For starters, the casting is impeccable, with Katharine Hepburn as Eleanor of Aquitane and Peter OToole as Henry the II. The estranged couple only reunites during one fateful Christmas season, where the two must decide how to divide the inheritance amongst their sons. Their scheming eldest child, Richard the Lionhearted (Anthony Hopkins), is devious, duplicitous and deceitful and butts heads with Philip of France (Timothy Dalton) whose goal is to ultimately destroy the kingdom and take everything for himself. Secondly, this gives you a taste of English history and insight into how turbulent the monarchy has ALWAYS been. Eons before Prince Charles and Princess Diana, there was Queen Eleanor and King Henry. The lively scenes are brilliantly directed and Katharine Hepburn won a well-deserved Academy Award for Best Actress in this wonderful film. Dont miss out on this one.
Greatest Acting Ensemble     On: 2007-08-07

This is the greatest collective display of acting since Lumets "Long Days Journey Into Night" and its no accident that Hepburn leads it again. With crackling dialogue and moody photography, this film sets a standard in play adaptation that has never been surpassed. OToole proves that he is a legend, and, in his film debut, Hopkins proves himself ready to be his equal. But, it is Hepburn who sets new standards: her mirror scene is one of the greatest examples of internal life ever caught on film. Everyone who loves quality drama should have this disc.
My favourite movie     On: 2007-07-28

Ah!! I adore this movie!! The acting is wonderful (Katherine Hepburn won a much deserved Oscar), the scenery is gorgeous (it was filmed on location) and the script is hilarious.

The year is 1183 and King Henry II of England(Peter OToole) is worried about which one of his three sons will inherit his throne when he dies.

We have Prince Richard the Lion-heart(Anthony Hopkins) who has been in battle since he was sixteen years of age.

The middle child, Geoffrey (John Castle) who is a very sadistic and cruel man. By the way, where is Geoffs wife in this movie? According to the history books he was already married.

Then there is the bumbling, smelly, sixteen-year-old idiot, Prince John who is played by Nigel Terry.

Henry and his mistress Alis (a woman who is young enough to be Henrys daughter), have both decided to throw a Christmas court and let Henrys wife Eleanor of Aquitaine (Katherine Hepburn) out of prison so they can both fight over the children. Henry had his wife thrown in prison years ago because her and the boys fought against Henry in battle.

Henry also invites the King of France (Timothy Dalton) to court so he can discuss further matters. For the record Philip is Alis brother. Also, Eleanors first husband was Philip and Alis father.

Throughout the movie we learn a dark secret involving Philip and Richard. Philip throws this in Henrys face as sort of a revenge because Philip always believed that Henry was responsible for his fathers death.

Anyway, Im not going to go into further detail. This is a great movie, kinda wish it happened in real life. For the record, this is Timothy Dalton, Anthony Hopkins, John Castle and Nigel Terrys first movie.

I highly recommend everyone watch this movie. I know it comes on TCM quite a lot. Go watch it!!

10 stars

~~Kat

A Real Reel Treat     On: 2007-07-18

A thinking persons movie. Anthony Hopkins before Hannibal Lecter ruined him; Henry as only Peter OToole could portray him and Eleanor as only Hepburn could portray her! The dialog in this movie is phenomenal.
A Truly Great Film     On: 2007-07-03

This is a great film with unforgettable performances -- a classic by any definition. You cant really compare it to the drek that normally released as a movie today. Do yourself a tremendous favor and buy it!
Medieval dysfunction     On: 2007-06-28

It is Christmas, 1183 and aging King Henry II of England meets with his estranged wife Eleanor of Aquitaine to decide which of their three sons will inherit the kingdom upon Henrys death. Each has a favorite and one must be chosen, and through deception, torment, connivance and deceit the "family" follows through in their respective roles. It is a wonderful story and though the outcome is in doubt, one thing is certain....there will never be another Christmas like this one!

Strong performances are universally good in "The Lion in Winter" and Katharine Hepburn earned a much deserved Academy Award. Its a shame that Peter OToole didnt win as well, as the two are equally matched for spark-flying drama. A third dazzling performance is turned in by a young Timothy Dalton as King Philip of France.

Though as much as the drama is perfected, "The Lion in Winter" (1968) hasnt particularly worn the test of time well. The dialogue is kitschy, (sometimes unintentionally funny) and the dysfunction is all too broad. Emotions change faster than you can snap your fingers, so many of the scenes dont play out as well as they should. That said however, "The Lion in Winter" is worth seeing for Hepburn, OToole and Dalton. On that score, you wont be disappointed.
The Lion in Winter     On: 2007-06-28

Shot on location in France and the British Isles, and based on an excoriating play by Richard Goldman, "Lion" is a wit-fueled, magnificently acted parable of power-lust and extreme family dysfunction. OToole and Oscar winner Hepburn are superb as the grizzled, sarcastic regent and his cunning wife, locked in a never-ending exchange of venomous criticisms. A youthful Anthony Hopkins, in a spirited turn, pops off some of the best insults. Aside from the endless machinations of various family members, Harvey adds period flavor with authentic costumes and gloomy, tone-perfect settings. When this "Lion" roars, youll be hooked.
The "Lion" roars     On: 2007-06-14

"The Lion in Winter" is one of the best films ever made. It has the language, scope and beauty of a great Shakespearean play. It also has two magnificent performances by OToole (King Henry II) and Hepburn (Queen Eleanor)and a fine early film appearance by Anthony Hopkins (Richard the Lionhearted). It concerns the struggle of Henrys three sons to take the crown and King Philip of France (Timothy Dalton) is willing to use Richards love for him to destroy the kingdom.
Start to finish great performances.     On: 2007-06-06

Great storyline. Untoppable Performances. I keep buying copies, because my friends keep making off with them. This one dosnt dissapoint.
Well, What Family Doesn't Have Its Ups and Downs?     On: 2007-06-02

"Katharine Hepburn, from her first scene when she is briefly taken out of her 10-year imprisonment, shows a wonderful relish for even the most unimpressive sarcastic line. "Well, what family doesnt have its ups and downs," she says, when sodomy, patricide, treason and incest are running their daily course. There is something about an actress with this degree of presence and a wholly distinct, pleasant and idiosyncratic voice that gets her through even misplaced weepy or extravagant scenes." Renata Adler

How many times can you watch a masterpiece and not get tired of it? Apparently as many as you want. Thus The Lion In Winter is the masterpiece for me. The action is contained within one day,Christmas Eve. Henry II, Peter OToole is 50 years old and wants to choose his heir before he dies. He has three sons: John, his favorite; Richard, the soldier genius; and Geoffrey, reserved and quiet. Henry calls a Christmas court, letting his wife, Eleanor of Aquitaine Katharine Hepburn out of prison for the occasion. King Philip of France is also a visitor. He wants to know when his sister will be married to the heir to the throne. But, Henry has not been able to appoint an heir yet, and whats more, the girls become his mistress. This film marks the debut of Anthony Hopkins, as Richard the Lion-Hearted, Nigel Terry as the adolescent Prince John; John Castle, as Prince Geoffrey; and Timothy Dalton, as Philip of France. This film brought forth many Oscars and they deserve to be mentioned.

Katherine Hepburn-Eleanor of Aquitaine brought Hepburn her third of four Oscars.

Peter OToole- Nominated but did not win-Best Actor

James Goldman- Best Screenplay

Anthony Harvey- Best Director

Margarret Furst- Best Costume Design

Because of the powerful acting we know at the outset that the outcome will be a result of power, politics and will. The stakes grow high as the film moves along until there is no game any longer only reality. The emotional tug of war is palpable between the Queen and King. The issues of trust, love and honor are at stake. This film takes on the human emotions and the full realm of laughter, smiles, tears and anger invade our souls. We root for the Queen until her manipulation has so evidently destroyed her family. We feel sorrow for the three sons, until their foibles become self-evident. The King is the King and thus all powerful. And,the mistress is but the pawn in this game.

"Jesus himself would have a hard time bringing peace to this yuletide household. Heres a family whose every deed and word is a chess move or a dagger stroke. After all, theres more at stake than merely the future of England and France. Alliances (political and sexual) rise and fall amid skillful maneuvering, clashing, and scheming for Henrys throne. At the center of this regal melee are Henry and Eleanor, whose combination of high mutual fondness and take-no-prisoners warfare -- on battlefields and in bedrooms -- make them one of cinemas great complicated relationships."
Mark Bourne

If there are any neophytes out there who have not seen this film- take thee to the nearest DVD store. A film not to be missed.
Highly, Highly Recommended. prisrob 6-02-07


Most rewarding     On: 2007-05-13

Absolutely excellent. The real purpose for the purchase was to have this great film on DVD. I curently have it on tape and by now it is worn out. Hepburn and OToole are exquisite. You feel as though you are right there in the mix of things, and oh what a mix. Would recommend it to everyone.
GREAT MOVIE     On: 2007-04-05

If you like historical movies, youll love this. Acting is superb, story is interesting and visuals are great.
This film is actually a 10+     On: 2007-03-17

This film has unbelieveably wonderful performances from the entire cast, but especially from Katharine Hepburn and Peter OToole. You will enjoy this movie for its background in English history, but Henry and Eleanor take the prize. The dialogue is extraordinary, and what is said between Henry and Eleanor is one of the most delicious things about the movie.
Fabulous Performances     On: 2007-03-14

This is one program I really dont care how historically accurate it is - Katharine Hepburn and Peter OToole are such a joy to watch.
Pete & Kate     On: 2007-03-09

Stellar performances by OToole and Hepburn. King Henry #2 and his fair Lady, Eleanor full of intrigue and princely plots. Love me, hate me, leave me episodes throughout. In the end King is jubilant, queen goes back to jail and the 3 naughty boys resume their plotting to seize the throne. "O well, what family doesnt have its ups and downs "? This is an oldie but a goodie !
Disappointment
by: v-r-h    On: 2007-03-09

This movie has been restored and digitally remastered. Fantastic cast and Katherine Hepburn won a Best Actress Academy Award for the performance. I did not realize it was going to be a "Whos Afraid of Virginia Wolfe" movie--very tedious to listen and watch the bickering and one-ups-manship. I did not finish viewing this movie and resold it. The talents of the actors were wasted on this movie.
Royal Misgivings
by: jpski3332002    On: 2007-03-05

A Lion in Winter has an irresistible match up between Peter OToole and Katherine Hepburn. Coming off like a comedic version of Whos Afraid of Virginia Woofe? in royal proportions, A Lion... has Henry II and Eleanor of Aquataine squaring off about which of their sons will succeed him when he dies. Living with a mistress, Alais (Jane Merrow) most of the time anyway, Henrys tempestuous relationship with Eleanor is a thorn in each others sides. And, while it may be a matter of taste how much their disputes reach decibel levels, it is only proportionate to the wit and laughter it provides the audience.

Henry wants John (Nigel Terry) to succeed him (someone only a dim person couldnt perceive is immature. His voice seems so common and whiney, I couldnt help but think of Eric Idle of Monty Python fame being equally suited for the role.) Then, Eleanor prefers Richard (Anthony Hopkins!) her favorite. Hes more well-groomed, but doesnt have the manhood. Geoffrey is the linch-pin, however; for like many families, the one whos scorned lives by his wits. Indeed he does. With Philip II of France (Timothy Dalton!) having a prolonged visit, the stakes of war over succession and negotiation up the ante quite a bit.

With a script that is often hysterical (in both senses of the word) and an able cast, A Lion in Winter is hardly what I expected. Instead of some sweeping epic with pomp and circumstance, we get an engaging ensemble that delivers great gifts, even from a royal family who seems needy and out of sorts during the holidays.

Too much of a good thing?     On: 2007-02-17

Wonderful cast. Fascinating plot. Too much intrigue.

Intrigue was expected, even eagerly anticipated, but every single cast member was trying to manipulate each and every other cast member to such a great extent that not a single word was believable, and I had no idea what anyones true motives were. At first it was interesting and challenging, but at some point it went overboard and I lost interest. Only OTooles Henry II character showed enough humanity that I cared what happened to him. The others went overboard in my view.

Interesting and well acted, but not a classic in my opinion.
Great Movie about Dysfunctional Family at Christmas     On: 2007-01-11

What can you say about the ultimate dysfunctional family. King Henry keeps his wife locked in a castle miles away and only lets her out on Holidays. Its a great Christmas Movie... Think Im nuts? Watch the film. You cant beat Peter OToole and Kate Hepburn duking it out over which of three unsavory Sons will take over the realm. It was a terrific play, and translates well to the screen. Killer dialogue. The DVD its self was a good widescreen transfer. Nothing major in the Extras category, but a solid DVD of a terrific Movie. I wish theyd hurry up and put out Becket.
23 years old and it holds up     On: 2006-12-31


Having just read the Alison Weir bio of Eleanor, I re-viewed this film that I had seen when it was in the theaters. As a film, only the sound betrays its age. For me, it was even better with the background fresh in my mind.

The movie provokes thought. While this is a hypothetical Christmas, the real ones must have been something like this. The facts of history are all on display, Alys and her dowery, the French king (son of Eleanors first husband) ever ready to deal, the dubious sexuality of Richard, control of the Aquitaine, the naming of a successor before primogeniture was institutionalized, Henrys love child Geoffrey. The casting is perfect especially Hepburn and OToole, I cant imagine any others in these roles. The acting, the sets, the costumes... first rate. The ending is wonderful.

While the script is fantastic, it is only one reading of history. While this family has to be as complex and dysfunctional as the movie portrays, I think its hard on Eleanor. She was a landed woman in her own right, and Henry was a philanderer of the first order, how SHOULD she have reacted? John might be overplayed as a simpleton, but when he does become king, he loses almost all of Englands continental lands and signs away some rights of kings (Magna Carta). No wonder Eleanor wants Richard to be king.


Second best performance not given an Oscar...     On: 2006-12-16

...Peter Otoole got cheated for the first also. This is simply amazing dialogue, performed with unbelievable energy and pacing. Few movies improve with each viewing, but this is it. Simply grand.
A dysfunctional British royal family??? Who'da thunk it???     On: 2006-10-20

Im not going to attempt to compose a brilliant summary of this extraordinary film. Others have done an excellent job of that already. I merely wish to add my voice to those proclaiming "The Lion In Winter" as a masterpiece.

Even if the script WERE less than brilliant, a cast such as this could most likely win awards just reading aloud from the Peoria, Illinois telephone directory.

Oh, and just in case you wonder what relevance this historically based film might have for us today, consider that it was John [eventually crowned king] who signed the "Magna Carta" in the year 1215. This document was the first in British history in which a king agreed [admittedly under great pressure] to limit his monarchic power.

This, then, became the cornerstone of what was later to emerge as Englands limited parliamentary monarchy and that of other nations as well. It further becomes the inspiration for limited government in general and more specifically for that republic that was to eventually emerge in the colonies across the big pond, so to speak.

Consider also that Richard was to go on and become King Richard II, famous for his crusades to the Holy Land.

Relevant today? You BET. And never was learning history so enjoyable as this film makes it.


Marry Me, "Lion In Winter"--Be My Queen     On: 2006-10-16

How much do I love "The Lion in Winter"? Lets just say that if man and DVD union were legal in the state of Nevada, Id rush over to the new Hooters Casino Chapel and get a quickie marriage to it. Wed live happily for a time and rear three supremely ungrateful children--the oldest of which would bear a striking resemblance to Hannibal Lecter. Someday, though, I know a Deluxe version DVD is going to come out with lots of great features. Im going to need to upgrade! But instead of just throwing my old copy of "The Lion In Winter" away, Id banish it to someplace where I wouldnt have to look at it anymore. Occasionally, though, Id feel nostalgic--especially around the holidays--Id cart it out to spend time with the family.

Seriously, "The Lion in Winter" is my favorite movie of all time. This is a brilliant film adaptation of a brilliant play, and I cherish it as perhaps the most literate film ever made! The screenplay won a well deserved Oscar, for this movie soars on its dialogue. It is merciless, gut-wrenching, hysterical, powerful and wickedly intelligent entertainment. The verbal bloodbaths, the vicious head games, the intentional cruelty--never has a Christmas been so entertaining. Dont be put off by the pedigree of talent involved with this film. It is not a staid, dignified chamber piece, NO! It is all out family warfare. It is also bitterly funny and uncompromising to the end.

Katherine Hepburn gives her finest performance in an Oscar winning role, and not to overstate it--but I think its one of the greatest film performances ever. Really. Peter OToole is dynamic and engaging, and every member of the cast is in fine form. Its especially interesting to see a young Anthony Hopkins and Timothy Dalton, complete with shocking (by 1968 standards) references to homosexuality. Sadly, its John Castle, as neglected middle child Geoffrey, who often gets overlooked in reviews of this film. Geoffrey, the child who no one claims, is easily the most worthy and most intelligent--yet his cry for attention manifests itself as cold-hearted manipulation. Middle child syndrome has never been so diabolically on point.

Through the years, I have made everyone I know watch this film. It is surprisingly contemporary. We see similar examples of family dysfunction every day in film and TV. But they arent usually Royals, and they arent as psychologically challenging. This is GRAND, FUNNY entertainment--and if you fashion yourself sophisticated and literate, this is a perfect movie. Even if you just like popcorn movies, you can enjoy this as extreme comedy.

Perfection.... KGHarris, 10/06.

Easily One Of The Greatest Films Ever Made     On: 2006-09-16

It is the Christmas season of the year 1183 and Englands wise but mercurial king, the aging Henry II, greatest figure in Europe since the death of Charlemagne, does what any good father would: he gathers his feuding family together for the holidays. Ah, but this is not merely any royal family, it is the Plantagents, a clan into whose roiling hearts treachery and violence have been bred as a way of life. There is Henrys oldest surviving son, Richard, later King Richard the Lionhearted, a cruel man who lives for war. There is also Henrys middle son, the cold, calculating Duke Geoffrey, and lastly, Henrys favorite, the spineless, conniving brat of the brood, the seemingly foolhardy but inwardly clever teenaged John, whom Henry wishes to one day succeed him as king. And above all this there is the greatest woman of the twelfth-century, Eleanor, Duchess of Aquitaine, Henrys wife, whom Henry has locked away in a castle for much of the recent past, revenge for one of Eleanors many attempts to wrest the kingdom from her much younger husband, a man she loves and hates with vying, passionate emotion. So into the mix they all go, each of these four dangerous individuals wishing to either wear the crown or see that a favored child does so.

Called together to celebrate the festive season, Henrys family hosts a rival king, the cerebrally-adept Philippe Auguste of France, barely more than a boy but clearly quite taken with being king. It is to Philippes lovely sister, Alais, that Henrys son Richard is nominally betrothed, but whom Henry has amorally made his mistress for the past several years. Philippe arrives with a demand: marry his sister to Richard at once---in effect making his future nephew king of England---or return those substantial French territories Philippes father turned over to Henry as Alais dowry. In an odd twist of feudal legalities, Henry, himself a king, is also a vassal of Philippe, even though there is the curious fact that Henry controls virtually as much of France as Philippe himself does. In their negotiations Henry dismisses Philippe as an inexperienced boy, and Philippe in return explains the cruel math of their situation, that simply put, time is on his side, and all he has to do is wait for Henry, a lion in winter, to die. When the two monarchs reach an impasse on the matter of Princess Alais, Philippe is only too ready to deal with Henrys plotting sons and wife, and the deal-making, each scheming side trying to gain better terms than the other, is a thing of great beauty to behold: like a venomous dance of dueling cobras.

In one poisonously-contested night the lives of each of the six principle figures of The Lion In Winter will be irrevocably changed, and how they all reach their end-points is an intricate tale well worth seeing. The performances in this production are without flaw, the dialogue is spoken in a rapid-fire pace simply unseen in films today---"When the kings off his arse, no one sleeps!"--- and the settings, all created in an age before computerized digital effects, are on a sweeping scale.

In the end one gets the sense that Henry, a man who conquered everything but time itself, a force against which no one is safe, was THEE man of his age, as Caesar was before him, Leonardo later was in his, or Bonaparte farther along. And yet we watch as despite all his stubborn brilliance the world Henry has made closes in on him through the course of one familial betrayal after another. Though The Lion In Winter ends on what passes for an optimistic note, anyone familiar with English history of the time knows, as Henry did not, what came next, and that shadow this knowledge casts across the near-jollity of the closing scene makes the conclusion all the more poignant.

Simply one of the greatest films that will ever be shot.
Christmas time with Henry II and family     On: 2006-09-03

I remember seeing this amazing film one day years ago and I recently rediscovered it. Henry II is the aging King of England whose oldest son and heir has died and so he must name a new heir. So he summons his family to Christmas court: His eldest son Richard is an able soldier, his politically astute middle son Geoffrey, and the spoiled youngest son John who Henry loves the best are the contenders for the throne. Also summoned are Henrys wife Eleanor who has been imprisoned in a tower, the young King of France Phillp and his sister Alais who is Henrys ward and mistress. All these characters have a different stake in the outcome of who becomes Henrys heir as they fight, plot and backstab to get their contender to the throne.

Some reviews have called his movie "wordy" and to be fair it is light on action but it is heavy on intrigue and almost every line in the script (especially those of Henry and Eleanor) is pure magic. The casting is superb with Peter OToole as Henry and Katharine Hepburn as Eleanor (She won an Oscar for this role). Look also for young Anthony Hopkins, Nigel Terry and Timothy Dalton. I highly recommend this intelligent and well casted costume drama to everyone.

MEET ELEANOR AND HENRY     On: 2006-08-01

This has to be my all-time favortie move. Singlehandedly it sparked my interest in British history. I saw it first in a theater and was overwhelmed, remembered it, and got a VHS version as soon as I was able. I have probably watched it at least 50 times since.
Katherine Hepburn and Peter OToole are just SUPURB as Eleanor and Henry. Henry Plantagenets rages were the stuff of legend during his lifetime, and the way OToole plays him you can see why. Why Peter OToole didnt get an Oscar for this I cant fathom. He IS Henry, as Eleanor says "With a mind like Aristotle and a form like mortal sin," just as Katherine Hepburn IS Eleanor, "I married out of love a woman out of legend..." It is almost like they channeled the personalities of these long-dead monarchs from the ether. Eleanor: "I rode bare-breasted half way to Damascus. Louie had a seizure and I nearly died of windburn....but the troops were dazzled."
I agree with the previous reviewer that Nigel Terry plays a dumbed-down, almost cariciture of John. John Castle plays Geoffrey to a "T", just how you would imagine him, caught between Richard and John, and coming up short in his parents regard. My only quarrel with anyone in the cast is Anthony Hopkins. He is a wonderful actor, maybe it was the director, but he just doesnt seem right for this part. The historical Richard oozed charisma and confidence, this Richard seems more stolid and repressed, but thats probably just me, since no one else seemed to have a problem with how he was portrayed. Though I will say that in the chamber scene with King Phillip and Henry he is outstanding. Timothy Dalton as Phillip is just perfect.
The dialogue is amazingly crisp and witty, and the attention to historical detail has been well-researched. This movie has an almost intimate feeling to it, as if you are watching the machinations and plotting of a very dynamic and even more dysfunctional family who just happen to rule England, Ireland and half of France. This has to rank up there with one of the finest films ever made.
The ultimate family Christmas movie
by: aclea    On: 2006-03-22

No movie sums up Christmas or brings back so many memories of Christmases Past than The Lion in Winter. Its 1183 and Henry IIs let his wife out of prison to decide the succession at Christmas court in Chinon: he favors John, she favors Richard and nobody cares for Geoffrey. Cue daggers, plots and reopened wounds as everyone tries to kill everyone else and nobody gets what they wanted for Christmas. Part costume drama, part Whos Afraid of Eleanor of Aquitaine? as these jungle creatures scratch and claw at each others weak spots and almost certainly a lot closer to history as it was lived than as it is written thanks to a truly great screenplay by James Goldman (who stumbled across the plot while researching a play about Robin Hood that would later become the sadly underrated Robin and Marion) thats done justice by its cast. Katherine Hepburn may have got the Oscar, but Peter OToole before the rot set in, reprising and bettering his role from Beckett, matches her tooth and claw, with Anthony Hopkins, Timothy Dalton and John Castle picking up a few tricks en route. The weak links are the reliably awful Nigel Terrys overstated John and Jane Merrows Alais, a performance as flat as her singing voice, but as they are required to be simpletons and ciphers they dont get in the way. Terrific nasty fun.

Classic wit     On: 2006-03-08

Two generations of rival royals from the twelfth century match wits and sovereign powers in provocative drama. Goldmans dialogue eschews anachronism, and the cast recreates the medievals in the most believable way possible.
Awesome Acting     On: 2006-02-24

This classic is one of the best movies ever made with an all star cast of actors and actresses that bring the characters to life, in the time span of just one day you have so many emotions and twists involving some of the greatest people in the history of Great Britain and France, this is truly history that is exciting and entertaining to watch.
Hepburn & O'Toole are Regal Treachery     On: 2006-01-09

King Henry II (Peter OToole), his wife Eleanor (Kate Hepburn) and their three sons Richard (the Lionhearted) (Anthony Hopkins in his film debut), John (Nigel Terry) and Geoffrey (John Castle) all get together for Christmas and treachery.

Henry and Eleanor have been battling for years - shes tried to overthrow him more than once. She is imprisoned in a castle and brought out for state occasions and holidays.

Its Christmastime and Henry is allowing Eleanor out for the festivities. Of course, also attending is his current paramour, Alais. But the problem really is her brother Philip, King of France is also attending and he wants Henry to marry his sister to one of his sons.

The son who marries Alais will be the next King of England. A marriage to Richard, Eleanors favorite son, would make him too powerful. Therefore, he favors the weaker son, John. Therefore, all three sons are vying for her.

This creates a lot of backstabbing and treachery including from Philip. The only pawn seems to be Alais.

The writing is delightfully wicked. Hepburn and OToole just eat it up and both give their best performances. This is a master class in acting, screenwriting and directing. This film will keep you on the edge of you seat waiting for the next turn.

My favorite line is when Henry storms out of Eleanors quarters saying he is going kill all their sons. Eleanor throws herself at Henry and just misses grabbing him and say "Well every family has their ups and downs."

Also, Hepburn won her third Academy Award in a historic tie with Barbra Streisand (Funny Girl) and James Goldman won for Screenplay. Anthony Harvey became the first director to win the Directors Guild Award but not the Oscar.

DVD EXTRAS: Commentary by Anthony Harvey

Family Angevin of Plantagenet will never be the same
by: Anonymous    On: 2005-12-18

Henry Plantagenet II has never been more humorously represented. A very bold movie. Definitely a triumph! Middle Ages England at its most clear-cut, most certainly. Captures the perverseness of the Catholic Church in that time, and the ways in which monarchs could worm out of anything. Applause doesnt do it proper service!
One of the 20 best films ever made -- period     On: 2005-11-16

I saw this movie in a theater when it was first released. I have also seen it about four or five times since on TV. Trust me, the big screen is much better, but even on TV, this movie has such incredible depth that it will be around for many years to come. The somewhat recent TV production with Patrick Stewart and Geln Close as Henry and Eleanor was very good, but not in the same league as Peter OTooles Henry and Katherine Hepburns Eleanor.

This film has perhaps some of the most crisp and witty dialog Ive ever heard. I always thought Peter OToole should have got an Oscar for his work in this film, and also for his excellent work in Beckett.

Set in 1183 in England, the film portrays the venemous relationship between Henry and Eleanor and their three sons, John Geoffrey and Richard. Beneath the venom and hurt is something of a bond of love between Eleanor and Henry that unfolds throught the film. Also, not to be missed is a young Anthony Hopkins as Richard, who in history is the Richard The Lion Heart who goes to the crusades, and in his absence England is ruled by his brother John, aho in 1215 is forced to sign the Magna Charta.

There are so many excellent reviews of this film that I feel inadequate to improve on them. Let me just say that if you want to spend a couple hours watching two of the worlds greatest actors work with a sparkling script and an outstanding set, then get this movie. I dont see how you will disappointed.
All happy families are alike...     On: 2005-11-12

Its 1183. Henry II has summoned his wife and children to join him for the Christmas holiday. Its not for the joy of their company, for this family is unhappy in its own toxic way. This movie lays that toxicity bare, then sends these unhappy people back where they came from.

I love this movie. Its become my familys traditional Christmas movie (a tradition that my kids would probably jettison if they could, but if I have to watch The Aristocats every Saturday, they have to watch The Lion in Winter once a year). The dialogue, the acting, the scenery, it all comes together in one wonderful whole, which is odd because the parts really arent all that wonderful.

The dialogue is relentlessly witty. A small amount of wit makes dialogue sparkle, but this movie is one brilliant one-liner after another. Even poor John (presented here as a much bigger dolt than the historical evidence justifies) gets off the occasional zinger. I enjoy the verbal torrent, but sometimes it makes me feel like Im drowning in the words.

The actors seem to love their lines; they deliver them with relish. They chew on them, roll them around, wallow in them, declaim and shout and hiss them with shameless promiscuity. Overacting? Oh, yes. But this was a stage play before it was a movie, and it may be that the exaggerated emotion thats necessary on stage was carried into the film out of force of habit.

The setting and scenery are dreary, though there are some lovely shots at the beginning and end of the movie when Eleanor arrives and then leaves by water. The castle looks cold and uncomfortable - in a word, authentic. Its a place where a family can fall apart with bitter recriminations all around and not make the house any more unpleasant a home than it already is.

All that is beside the point, because the elements of this movie come together in a beautifully harmonious way. Through all the anger and bitterness we can see the embers of the love that bound Henry and Eleanor. Their sons are cold and cynical and manipulative, but we sense the regret, the love that might have been, if only the royal court werent so cold and deadly a place. The story is sad, but it shines with humor and that endless torrent of wit. The acting is over the top, but the actors play characters who are grander and meaner than life, people whose lives are over the top.

Katharine Hepburn is radiant in this film; Peter OToole is magnificent. Nigel Terry is deliciously low as John, and Anthony Hopkins is a sadly damaged Richard. There was no one in this film I didnt like, either as a character or as an actor.

This isnt a film for people who want action or subtlety in their movies (thought it does have both). You have to enjoy a certain amount of chattiness, not mind scenes that dont actually lead anywhere. What youll get in return is an ultimately optimistic view of life, which for all its pettiness and disappointments can always hold out the promise of something grand and wonderful.

The Best Movie Ever Made     On: 2005-11-11

This witty, intelligent and perfectly acted film is my favorite movie, and one I recommend everyone see.

Peter OToole and Katherine Hepburn are unforgetabble. Rent or buy it today - you wont be sorry.


A glorious movie!     On: 2005-10-12

Lion in Winter has it all--marvelous acting, great dialog, compelling characters, and a terrific story. It deals with the family of Henry II of England (the aging "Lion") and his estranged wife (is "estranged" the right word? Hes had her in prison for years) Eleanor of Aquitaine--two of English historys most intriguing characters. Look for a young Anthony Hopkins as the future Richard I and Timothy Dalton as the even younger king of France.

The movie is set at a Christmas court at Chinon at which Henry, Eleanor, their surviving sons Richard, Geoffrey, and John, and Richards fiancee (who is Henrys mistress and the French kings sister) are all present as the family deals with their complicated interrelationships as well as the question of who will be king after the aging Henry dies and how they will respond to the French kings visit. Historically, they did not gather at Chinon for a court that year, but the backstory, relationships, and agendas within this family are presented accurately. This is a film to treasure.
A Five-Star Classic     On: 2005-09-10

I cant say much about this movie that hasnt already been said. One point, however, that seldom is made is the great acting by Nigel Terry as Prince John. For those of you who dont mind a little legend mixed with your history, this is the prince who becomes King John of Robin Hood fame. Watching this movie, you can really envision Richard (the Lion-Hearted), as portrayed by Anthony Hopkins, riding off to the Crusades, leaving Terrys slimy John to rule. No wonder heroes like Robin Hood sprang up (if indeed he did).

Incidentally, Nigel Terrys next big role was as King Arthur in Excalibur. He gave a great performance in that, as well.

Own this movie.
Stunning Character Studies In Fine Historical Drama
by: novarro    On: 2005-08-29

When Katharine Hepburn as the wily Eleanor of Acquitaine states after one of the numerous family "clashes", in the classic 1968 historical drama "The Lion in Winter", that "all families have their ups and downs", she was probably making the biggest understatement of the century when one views this totally jaw dropping excursion into family conflict, intrigue and deception. Often quite rightly referred to as the "Medieval Whos Afraid of Virginia Woolf?", what this film may lack in continent-wide scope that one comes to expect from such historical dramas, the film more than makes up for in an almost savage and raw depiction of one family in disintergration, that being the less than perfect family of King Henry the Second of England. Told over the gathering of his totally unlovely clan for a Christmas Court at Chinon Castle, the occasion is anything but festive but luckily provides us viewers (who are thankfully watching the proceedings from the comfort of our far away living rooms!), with a superb series of human dramas and conflict that while emotionally draining to watch do nevertheless offer us some of the most splendid acting to come out of an historical drama during the 1960s and certainly preserves forever two of possibly the finest performances ever delivered by acting greats Katharine Hepburn and Peter OToole on screen.

Based on his acclaimed stage play "The Lion in Winter", by James Goldman the action unfolds as the family of King Henry the Second of England gathers for the annual Christmas court. His long estranged wife Queen Eleanor of Aquitaine is released from her own imprisonment where she has been detained for plotting against her husband, to attend and the couples less than perfect three sons Richard (Anthony Hopkins), Geoffrey (John Castle), and John (Nigel Terry), are also present but all have their own agendas and personal axes to grind. The tension is heightened by the fact that Henry also has his young mistress Alais (Jane Merrow), present who he intends to marry which guarantees an explosive family occasion. The gathering turns from being a Christmas get together into a cold blooded struggle for power to see which of the three sons will be named successor to Henry. Eleanor backs eldest son Richard despite his complete distrust in her while Henry favours youngest son John. Middle son Geoffrey is left to fight his own battles and matters are soon complicated by the arrival of King Philip of France (Timothy Dalton), who joins in the Christmas gathering and very soon is playing his own games to get what he wants against his hated rival King Henry. The Christmas period is a far from happy one as one member of the family sets out to destroy the other and the battle royale that takes place between Eleanor and Henry in actual fact achieves nothing as they fight themselves into a stale mate which is not resolved before the court breaks up and Eleanor returns to her captivity until the next time she is brought out for a family gathering. Meanwhile the war weary sons and their father must learn then to live with the fully exposed hatred and mistrust that they all feel for each other for another whole year with no one obtaining the promised crown that they all so murderously desire.

What really of course makes "The Lion in Winter", stand out so superbly even to the present day is the series of outstanding performances by both seasoned performers and from those often just starting out in their film careers. Katharine Hepburn in my belief has never been better than in this role and totally deserved her third Academy Award as Best Actress for 1968. She was a fascinating actress playing one of historys most fascinating women and rarely does a marriage of actress and role work so well as here where Hepburn plays Eleanor of Aquitaine as a seasoned manipulator out to play the battle of wits to the fullest against her husband so as to achieve what she wants for herself and her favourite son Richard. Despite the age difference between herself and Peter OToole never it seems have an historical couple been so realistically portrayed and you can almost see the the long festering battle scars of their turbulent marriage being reopened within the first 10 minutes of their first meeting. Despite their powerful acting off each other the younger members of the cast also manage to shine and Timothy Dalton in his screen debut as King Philip really excelss in his scenes as the devious King of France who is not above playing off one member of this sad family against the other to get what he wants. "The Lion in Winter", also contains interesting early work by the "three sons", Anthony Hopkins,( in a superb performance as the inwardly tormented and sexually confused eldest son Richard), John Castle as the hard to read middle son, and especially Nigel Terry who portrays youngest son John as an almost pathetic halfwit who nevertheless has a definite calculating side to him. "The Lion in Winter", is not your typical medieval epic full of bright costumes, jousting and fair maidens in distress and it is significant in actually trying to depict the court life of Henry the Second complete with its filth, poverty, lack of any real glamour, and spartan living conditions. While none of the characters are actually likeable these deglamourised surroundings suit the story perfectly in displaying a less than perfect environment for less than perfect individuals. The film at times does betray its stage origins however with the powerful dialogue that is being delivered that is not a major drawback. The action at times is "opened out", for the screen and we are treated to some wonderful vistas such as my favourite when we witness Queen Eleanors dramatic arrival at Chinon Castle on her barge wrapped in rich furs against a stark winter background. The period recreation in fact is first rate and is always how I would imagine a medieval Castle would look when fully inhabited by a sprawling court.

Watching "The Lion in Winter", is certainly both an exhausting and exhilarating experience for viewers and in this savage story of human nature at its worst you cant help but feel yourself drawn into the unpredictable and often deadly twists and turns of the plot and of the characters true intentions. More of a film that involves intense characterisations and crushing dialogue than historical pageantry "The Lion in Winter", works especially well in the acting department for that very reason where dialogue wins out over spectacle. Superb performances, a fine literate and at times disturbing script and just enough historical background combine here to make this film essential viewing for all lovers of early British history and for those that want to witness a family Christmas celebration like none they (hopefully), will experience themselves. Katharine Hepburn and Peter OToole rarely reached greater acting heights than in their performances here where they literally feed off each other to stunning dramatic effect. Be sure to savour the down side of playing the English succession game in the powerful movie version of John Goldmans "The Lion in Winter", soon.

Stunning Character Studies In Fine Historical Drama     On: 2005-08-28

When Katharine Hepburn as the wily Eleanor of Acquitaine states after one of the numerous family "clashes", in the classic 1968 historical drama "The Lion in Winter", that "all families have their ups and downs", she was probably making the biggest understatement of the century when one views this totally jaw dropping excursion into family conflict, intrigue and deception. Often quite rightly referred to as the "Medieval Whos Afraid of Virginia Woolf?", what this film may lack in continent-wide scope that one comes to expect from such historical dramas, the film more than makes up for in an almost savage and raw depiction of one family in disintergration, that being the less than perfect family of King Henry the Second of England. Told over the gathering of his totally unlovely clan for a Christmas Court at Chinon Castle, the occasion is anything but festive but luckily provides us viewers (who are thankfully watching the proceedings from the comfort of our far away living rooms!), with a superb series of human dramas and conflict that while emotionally draining to watch do nevertheless offer us some of the most splendid acting to come out of an historical drama during the 1960s and certainly preserves forever two of possibly the finest performances ever delivered by acting greats Katharine Hepburn and Peter OToole on screen.

Based on his acclaimed stage play "The Lion in Winter", by James Goldman the action unfolds as the family of King Henry the Second of England gathers for the annual Christmas court. His long estranged wife Queen Eleanor of Aquitaine is released from her own imprisonment where she has been detained for plotting against her husband, to attend and the couples less than perfect three sons Richard (Anthony Hopkins), Geoffrey (John Castle), and John (Nigel Terry), are also present but all have their own agendas and personal axes to grind. The tension is heightened by the fact that Henry also has his young mistress Alais (Jane Merrow), present who he intends to marry which guarantees an explosive family occasion. The gathering turns from being a Christmas get together into a cold blooded struggle for power to see which of the three sons will be named successor to Henry. Eleanor backs eldest son Richard despite his complete distrust in her while Henry favours youngest son John. Middle son Geoffrey is left to fight his own battles and matters are soon complicated by the arrival of King Philip of France (Timothy Dalton), who joins in the Christmas gathering and very soon is playing his own games to get what he wants against his hated rival King Henry. The Christmas period is a far from happy one as one member of the family sets out to destroy the other and the battle royale that takes place between Eleanor and Henry in actual fact achieves nothing as they fight themselves into a stale mate which is not resolved before the court breaks up and Eleanor returns to her captivity until the next time she is brought out for a family gathering. Meanwhile the war weary sons and their father must learn then to live with the fully exposed hatred and mistrust that they all feel for each other for another whole year with no one obtaining the promised crown that they all so murderously desire.

What really of course makes "The Lion in Winter", stand out so superbly even to the present day is the series of outstanding performances by both seasoned performers and from those often just starting out in their film careers. Katharine Hepburn in my belief has never been better than in this role and totally deserved her third Academy Award as Best Actress for 1968. She was a fascinating actress playing one of historys most fascinating women and rarely does a marriage of actress and role work so well as here where Hepburn plays Eleanor of Aquitaine as a seasoned manipulator out to play the battle of wits to the fullest against her husband so as to achieve what she wants for herself and her favourite son Richard. Despite the age difference between herself and Peter OToole never it seems have an historical couple been so realistically portrayed and you can almost see the the long festering battle scars of their turbulent marriage being reopened within the first 10 minutes of their first meeting. Despite their powerful acting off each other the younger members of the cast also manage to shine and Timothy Dalton in his screen debut as King Philip really excelss in his scenes as the devious King of France who is not above playing off one member of this sad family against the other to get what he wants. "The Lion in Winter", also contains interesting early work by the "three sons", Anthony Hopkins,( in a superb performance as the inwardly tormented and sexually confused eldest son Richard), John Castle as the hard to read middle son, and especially Nigel Terry who portrays youngest son John as an almost pathetic halfwit who nevertheless has a definite calculating side to him. "The Lion in Winter", is not your typical medieval epic full of bright costumes, jousting and fair maidens in distress and it is significant in actually trying to depict the court life of Henry the Second complete with its filth, poverty, lack of any real glamour, and spartan living conditions. While none of the characters are actually likeable these deglamourised surroundings suit the story perfectly in displaying a less than perfect environment for less than perfect individuals. The film at times does betray its stage origins however with the powerful dialogue that is being delivered that is not a major drawback. The action at times is "opened out", for the screen and we are treated to some wonderful vistas such as my favourite when we witness Queen Eleanors dramatic arrival at Chinon Castle on her barge wrapped in rich furs against a stark winter background. The period recreation in fact is first rate and is always how I would imagine a medieval Castle would look when fully inhabited by a sprawling court.

Watching "The Lion in Winter", is certainly both an exhausting and exhilarating experience for viewers and in this savage story of human nature at its worst you cant help but feel yourself drawn into the unpredictable and often deadly twists and turns of the plot and of the characters true intentions. More of a film that involves intense characterisations and crushing dialogue than historical pageantry "The Lion in Winter", works especially well in the acting department for that very reason where dialogue wins out over spectacle. Superb performances, a fine literate and at times disturbing script and just enough historical background combine here to make this film essential viewing for all lovers of early British history and for those that want to witness a family Christmas celebration like none they (hopefully), will experience themselves. Katharine Hepburn and Peter OToole rarely reached greater acting heights than in their performances here where they literally feed off each other to stunning dramatic effect. Be sure to savour the down side of playing the English succession game in the powerful movie version of John Goldmans "The Lion in Winter", soon.

Stunning dramatic force     On: 2005-08-26

A captivating and stunning drama with tremendous acting from Peter OToole as King Henry and Katherine Hepburn as his estranged wife Queen Eleanor. The first time I saw the film, it blew me away; holding my attention, no riveting it, all the way to the final scene with Prince Richard not flinching. And this in spite of the fact that like "A Man for All Seasons" there is not any action in the film, just on-stage dramatic tension. The second time through years later, the film still captivates, but not with the same overpowering force. It came across now more as a typical battle of the sexes in a marriage gone sour. Some say this is a historical piece. Not really. It is 20th-century Freudian psychology dressed up in 12th-century clothes. But never mind that, this is awesome dramatic acting that anyone in the 21st century can appreciate.
IT STINKS! IT'S A STINKER! AND IT STINKS!     On: 2005-08-22

Little goodies of dialog like that pollute the supposed tension throughout the film. It mightve be tragic if it wasnt so funny. It mightve been funny if it didnt try so hard to be tragic.

When I first saw the Lion in Winter in Western Civ class, I thought it was the worst movie Id ever seen. The rest of the class seemed to be in agreement. After a second viewing, I offer a full retraction. The story is actually very good, as are most of the performances. Unfortunately the film lacks the focus to be effective. While most of the actors did a good job in his or her own right, the chemistry between characters is on the level of a middle school production of Shakespeare.

Some of the scenes have a Python-esque charm to them, but the direction doesnt compliment it. And it shouldnt. Its not meant to be a spoof, but the more serious scenes lack the intensity of anything better. One of the biggest problems with the film is that it provides no emotional anchor with which the viewer can sympathize. It also sidesteps the personal conflicts in favor of portraying stategy. The result is like watching complete strangers playing chess. Today I also viewed Bergmans The Seventh Seal for the first time, a movie about a knight who plays chess with Death. It far surpasses this film in every way, shape, and form.

If those who made The Lion in Winter understood the material to the degree that Bergman did, this couldve been a great film. As is, it is a valiant attempt but an ultimate failure.
Pork in the Trees Come Morning
by: kevinkillian    On: 2005-08-18

Anthony Harvey, who replaced George Cukor as Katharine Hepburns favorite director during this period, had his work cut out for him just keeping a cast of hotheads in line. OToole and Hepburn get most of the plum dialogue, though Anthony Hopkins does well with his portion. Henry gets sarcastic and nasty, always taking the dim view of things, whereas Eleanor is more pragmatic and even optimistic. Who can forget their exchange about hell freezing over? "The day those stout hearts band together is the day that pigs get wings," he raves. She takes a moment, glances mischievously, and replies, "Therell be pork in the trees come morning." Indeed the movie is one long debate about human nature and how and if it came be improved.

When I was a boy my favorite play was Goldmans LION IN WINTER and Dad took me to the Broadway version which starred Rosemary Harris, then very young, probably not even thirty yet, and she was outstanding. It was hard to see how a woman so young could have given birth to three grown sons. In the Broadway cast some of the sons were probably older than Harris. But as anyone knows, she is an extremely powerful actress with a sort of ageless craggy look. Probably even as a baby she never looked young, and she was perfect as Eleanor.

Another prominent reviewer credits "Julie" Harris with creating the part on the stage. No sir, Im afraid youve got your Harrises mixed up. I like Julie Harris as an actress too, but the play would have ground to a halt with Julie Harris and her fey sweetness playing the tough as nails Eleanor of Acquitaine.

The play was great, but it didnt have Katharine Hepburn, and it didnt have the fantastic brass and metal clanging choral work of John Barrys famous film score. That music wont let you rest; more than any other element it brings the past into the action of the movie in an almost visceral way. You almost forget you dont actually speak Latin yourself, it sounds so natural.
What a Family!!     On: 2005-08-15

This film based upon the Play is just wonderful and from what I have seen is a very accurate about the Henry II and his extremely troublesome family.It has so many great lines and complex characters that it just overwhelms ones senses.
("I could of conquered all of Europe But I had Women in my Life!" or "Anything can happen if dead carpenters can rise from the Dead")
I have seen this film several times now and maybe I am not the sharpest knife in the drawer. But I always find something new and wonderful in this film. I can not recommend this film high enough to those who like the Middle Ages and the Father of the English Common Law! Mr. Otoole and Ms. Hepburn were never better than here. Even if they did not look like the originals.
(Henry was Fatter and Eleanor was was not so skinny either.)
"It's the way I register dispair..."     On: 2005-08-06

So says Queen Eleanor when the King Henry notes that, amid the disasters of her life; her treacherous children and her imprisonment at the hands of her husband; she is still smiling.

I was in high school when The Lion in Winter was released. I had not so long before seen Becket, also starring OToole (with Richard Burton), and was looking forward to a much more action-oriented, swash-buckling movie than is The Lion in Winter. So I recall being disappointed with the endless talking much of which didnt make sense to me, the dark scenes and the nastiness of the characters. Not much medieval spleandor!

Well, that was in my impatient, impetuous youth. Now that we live in the DVD age these old gems can be brought out for reappraisal. The film requires a certain level of maturity and patience to be appreciated, but once that threshold is reached the rewards of this movie are rich and manifold.

The film rates as one of my favorites. Though I respect the Halliwell Film and Video Guide (which, happily, is very grudging with the stars), it grossly underrates this wonderful movie (giving it one star, when it should rate at least three).

The main problem of the story is transitioning the monarchy from an aging king to a successor. The way this up-for-grabs power struggle effects the characters is brilliantly presented in dialog and acting. The King tries out one decision out after another: first one prince, then another, will inherit the throne, then, realizing that all of his sons display varying levels of treachery, the King decides he needs a new heir. He will go to Rome for a divorce so he can remarry to have more sons. But that wont work since all the princes and the Queen threaten to revolt.

The Kings dithering has a corrosive effect on the characters which is fascinating to watch. The trust and distrust of each individual to the others, the loyalty or betrayal to the King and the current favorite causes great volatility in the alliances between characters.

The story is, finally, a tragedy. Its the tragedy of growing old, of realizing that one doesnt live forever and will never know, much less control, how the world will turn out when one is gone. The tragedy of being shunted aside (as is the imprisoned Queen), of seeing your children not live up to your expectations and then become disloyal. The tragedy for two of the three princes not chosen to rise to the throne.

At the end of the story, nothing is decided. Life will go on as before. The Queen is on her way back to jail. But the King and Queen have learned that they are companions in their mutual tragedy. In the midst of this sorrow the lighthearted way they part brings a tear to the eye. Indeed, their final fairwell is a triumph over dispair.
Hard to take after all these years     On: 2005-08-06

By far the worst part of this mess is the writing - the LANGUAGE, for petes sake - EMBARRASSING. Pure 1960s post-playboy-sexual-liberation titillation. Eleanor of Aquitaine declaiming about sex in history. Sure...

Then theres the heavy-handed scenery-chewing scream-to-the-rafters ham acting. Dont know who the worst offender is here, OTooles bull-bellowing or Hepburns chatty aging cocktail party diva (all she needed was a cigarette holder, rawly my deah).

Even the makeup was hideous, especially Kates, so mid-20th century garish, but then it always was in these 1960s wide-screen "pageants".

Whatever else this monstrosity is its the very opposite of Shakespearean.
You're Still My Lady...     On: 2005-07-26

Welcome to the world of the Plantagenets. At Christmas Court, Peter OToole and Katharine Hepburn portray Henry II and Eleanor of Acquitaine trying to select a successor to the throne. Now this is what can be truly called..Acting..in all its senses. They both bring such strength and believability to their respective roles that you really feel what the twelfth century court could have been like.
After all the fights, plots and vicious verbal battles are thrown around, you still feel the love, care and respect that Henry and Eleanor had for one another. This is the kind of movie that should make anyone want to learn more about Medieval History. A one of a kind movie that shouldnt be missed.
King Lear Retold     On: 2005-07-23

It is Christmastime in medieval England. King Henry II of England (Peter OToole) summons his family. What appears to be an innocuous holiday is anything but that. For the House of Henry II Plantagenet is a dysfunctional and quarrelsome one, and the ageing monarch wishes to appoint a suitable heir to the throne amidst this background.

Queen Eleanor of Aquataine (Katharine Hepburn), whom Henry has imprisoned for many years, connives to install her favourite son, Prince Richard the Lionheart (Anthony Hopkins). Henry would be amenable to this except that Richard had a homosexual relationship with King Philip of France (Timothy Dalton), and consequently he favours Prince John (Nigel Terry), his teenage, albeit half-witted son. Prince Geoffrey (John Castle), the aloof and least loved heir, plays a cat-and-mouse game with his parents and brothers simply for the pleasure of tormenting them. It is a tempestuous situation to say the least, yet therein lies the beauty of "Lion in Winter".

To witness the exchange of dialogue and brinkmanship between OToole and Hepburn is hypnotic, as are the performances of a young Anthony Hopkins and Nigel Terry. You cant help but be consumed and drawn into this royal familys emotional roller-coaster and feel sympathetic for their plight. Timothy Dalton (aka James Bond), in a rather lacklustre performance, makes his film debut in this film. But it is Hepburn and OToole who hold this film together.

The script, costumes, scenery and photography are excellent. Although, I am inclined to agree with the director, Anthony Harvey, the films weakness lies in the occasional zoom shot. But then, I dont suppose many viewers would notice it unless it was called to their attention.

Anthony Harveys scene by scene account, which may be heard while the movie plays, is an insightful footnote into his editing, directing style and rapport with his actors. He sheds light on how he created the mood for merry olde England; how he let the camera roll allowing the actors to perform at length uninterrupted; and how the actors prepared for their roles and worked as a family.

Suffice it to say, "Lion in Winter" is King Henry IIs winter of discontent. It is one mans tragic realisation in the winter of his life that he can only survive so long as he is politically and physically strong. There can never be -- and history shows there never was -- any compromise for Henry II. It is this honest and realistic depiction of his life and family that makes the story for "Lion in Winter" so compelling, so fantastic.




Historical masterpiece
by: coryslip    On: 2005-07-14

Both Peter OToole and Katherine Hepburn were wondrous in their roles of King Henry II and his queen Eleanor of Aquitane in the brilliantly directed historical drama "The Lion in Winter".

In Christmastime of 1183 and Henry decides to assemble his fractured family at Chinon castle to decide who while assume the throne of England among his 3 sons, Richard, Geoffrey and John. King Phillip of France played by a young Timothy Dalton and his sister Alais, Henrys mistress are also among the guests. The scheming Eleanor who has been imprisoned by Henry but released for this occasion favors Richard played by Anthony Hopkins in one of his first starring roles.

The drama plays out revealing to OToole that none of his traitorous sons is worthy of the throne and the decision is left undecided.

"The Lion in Winter" was highlighted by powerful acting performances which garnered Hepburn an Oscar but sadly not one for the deserving OToole, who put on an acting clinic. The scenery did much to enhance the historical quality of the film. The flick was an effectively produced piece that made a neat transition from the stage to the screen.
A Royal Dispute
by: rivalax    On: 2005-05-03

Anthony Harvey directs this 1968 film based on a screenplay by James Goldman on the reigns of Henry II of England (Peter OToole) and his wife, Eleanor of Aquitaine (Katherine Hepburn.) The film is more a theatrical piece as it is shot almost entirely in a studio/indoors and is also equally devoid of any action besides dialogue: but what great dialogue! Worthy even of the Bards applause!

In the late 12th century, the royal Norman family of Anjou/Plantagenet is in a squabble. Eleanor DAquitaine is hostage to her husband Henry II in an English castle and each place their weight with their sons to ensure their prosperous reign in the years to come. Princes John (Nigel Terry: Arthur in Excalibur) and Richard (Anthony Hopkins) come to meet their feuding parents on Christmas Eve to discuss the succession to the throne. Intrigue is plenty as each monarch seeks to win the allegiance of their favorite son: one prefers the fierce Richard while the other prefers the moody Prince John. Theres also a brief appearance by the King of France Philippe Le Bel (Timothy Dalton.) Again, the film has no action and the scenes are primarily limited to Eleanors place of confinement. The script/dialogues are excellent and filled with passion and intrigue. A great film showing the woes of monarchy and succession and the intrigues of Medieval courts.

This is a powerful drama providing a good glimpse into the complexities of Medieval dynasties and English/French history. The disputes represented in the film were never really settled as Henrys marriage to Eleanor would later become the grounds of the Hundred Years War between England and France during the 14th-15th centuries. This film is ideal for audiences who either like history and/or theatrical dramatic plays as opposed to purely action-based Hollywood drama. For a good fictional novel on this subject, I would recommend Maurice Druons saga titled Les Rois Maudits (English translations are available) covering the dynastic reigns of England and France during the Middle Ages: an excellent work of literature. For a romantic novel on this period, the best is probably Sir Walter Scotts Ivanhoe which covers in rich and abundant detail all of the nuances of English culture/politics during that period of time.
One of the best movies ever made     On: 2005-04-26

I think this is one of Katharine Hepburns greatest performances (for which she did win an Academy Award for). I cant imagine anybody else playing the role of Eleanor of Aquitaine in this movie. Peter OToole (as King Henry II of England) should have won an Academy Award for Best Actor (he was nominated). This movie is gripping and mesmerizing. The dialogue is so clever and well written with lots of dark wicked humor. There is fighting between Eleanor and King Henry II, a dysfunctional family, all the sons fighting for the throne and lots of conniving, backstabbing and scheming. What more can you ask for? The acting is superb. Its one of the best movies ever made, in my opinion and one of my favorites. If you are a history buff, you have to see this movie. If you love powerful performances, clever dialogue, and strong characters, you have to see this movie. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS MOVIE! My rating: A+
Beautifully acted film on bargain priced DVD     On: 2005-03-12

This wonderful historical bitchfest is colorfully preserved on DVD with a "cozy" bonus directors commentary (Youll feel like youre with Anthony Harvey, screening it in a drawing room...cigar and brandy, anyone?). The movie is definitely 1960s in style and design, but it doesnt distract from the pure pleasure of this dramatic version of the reign of Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine, brilliantly played by Peter OToole and Oscar winner Hepburn.

Timothy Dalton and Anthony Hopkins strut their early promise with vigor. Too bad one or both of them couldnt have been enticed to reunite for a commentary track. It would also have been nice to include a bonus feature with some historical information on the real-life characters portrayed.

Certainly a great motion picture for your DVD classics collection.
All Families Have Their Ups and Downs
by: dave3679    On: 2005-03-06

Christmas 1183: King Henry II (Peter OToole) in the September of his years is doing a little estate planning by choosing a successor and dividing up the kingdom. He summons his three sons and his estranged wife, Eleanor(Katharine Hepburn), who has been imprisoned for plotting civil war against Henry, for a Christmas court. All the best laid plans of mice and men. Naturally, there are resentments among the boys as to who should succeed Henry and Eleanor gleefully stokes the fire of this powderkeg. To say sparks fly is an understatement. The raw emotion on display here is a virtual inferno and the only beneficiary is a delighted audience. Anthony Harvey colorfully transfers James Goldmans play to the screen. OToole, who in my mind deserved the Oscar for his work here, literally explodes on the screen as Henry. He is literally a lion personified. Hepburn, who did win the Oscar, gives a multi-hued performance here. Yes, she is devious and unrelenting, but there is an underlying sadness in her character. You can see on her face that she rues the sad state of affairs she finds herself in. The joy of this film is to watch these accomplished actors tackle great dialogue which is a rarity in films these days.
The "Lion" Roars With Power
by: thehappyhungarian    On: 2005-03-01

There are movies I see now and then that impress me so much with their acting Im speechless. I find it hard to convey just how much I truly appreciate it. One this list goes "A Streetcar Named Desire", Brando and Leigh Ive always felt are almost battling over who will be more memorable, or "Rachel, Rachel" Woodard just seems to be that character nothing more can be said or Gena Rowlands in "A Woman Under the Influence" then there are modern film such as "21 Grams". I thought "Grams" was the best film of 2003 strongly because of the acting and here we have Anthony Harveys "Lion in Winter" and once again Im blown away. How this movie lost the Academy Award to "Oliver" makes my head spin. Here, without doubt is the best film of 1968.

Originally a play written by James Goldman, who also adapted his own screenplay, is a film that reaches a Shakespearian level of drama. Like Shakespear we have a story that deals with lust, greed, and revenge.

King Henry II (Peter O Toole) must decide which of his three sons will be his succesor. He has his own favorite, as does his wife Eleanor (Katherine Hepburn). Soon the sons are plotting against one another and their father. Meanwhile Henry and Eleanor are at each others throat as their marriage is one in name only.

The way the cast, which includes Anthony Hopkins (making his screen debut) and Timothy Dalton, Jane Merrow and John Castle actually seem to become these characters is the strenght of the film.

In trying to be objective and present both sides to you Im finding it difficult to think of the films flaws. If anything perhaps the ending is disappointing only because we thought there was a resolution between two of these characters. But, other than that I cant think of any other flaws to point out.

The movie was nominated for seven Oscars and won three; "best actress", "best screenplay", and "best score". To me this is one of the ultimate masterpieces.

Bottom-line: A masterpiece that hits a level of drama only matches by Shakespear. Has some of the most powerful acting you will find in a Hollywood film.
One great movie!     On: 2005-02-24

Stunning acting and dialogue. From sheer laughter to neurotic sulking: Hepburn, OToole, and playwright James Goldman deliver an epic.
They don't make them like this anymore     On: 2005-01-28

See my review of the 2004 remake as contrast.
This is, simply put, the greatest movie I have ever seen.
Peter OToole is exactly how I pictured Henry II: arrogant and volatile, yet somehow sympathetic; he can calmly discuss one minute and roar the next like the titular character he is. Hepburn as Eleanor is brilliant, a latter-day Helen whose beauty has long since started to fade, living to scheme against Henry and to manipulate her sons against him and against one another. The supporting cast, including the debut performances of Timothy Dalton and Anthony Hopkins, is similarly spectacular. Lets just say this is Richard the Lionhearted as you never imagined him.
But the acting skill of the cast is only half of the game; part of the genius of this film lies in its dialogue. There is almost no action and yet never a dull moment (this from someone who likes big explosions as much as the next theatergoer). The quips and jokes, jabs and insults, are delivered with impecable timing.
My favorite exchange:
Henry (roaring, and dripping with sarcasm): How was your crossing? Did the sea part for you?
Eleanor (calmly, and equally sarcastic): It went flat when I told it to. I didnt think to ask for more.

Wow.
Christmas 1183, and all's not well.....
by: bekintex    On: 2005-01-13

King Henry II has let his Queen, Elinor of Aquitaine, out of prison for the Christmas holidays. He also plans to name a successor, since their eldest son Henry III is dead. Problem is, he favors the youngest, John, while Elinor favors the eldest, Richard. King, Queen, Princes John, Richard, and Geoff, King Phillip of France and his sister, Alais all wrestle for position in this not for the faint of heart family drama.

Richard OToole and Katharine Hepburn deliver one of their best performances in their roles. This is one of the first times I recall seeing Anthony Hopkins (Richard) and Timothy Dalton (Phillp).

The only negative I can post is the soundtrack. Im not sure the Latin chants are quite appropriate to the action. Have been tempted to turn off the opening music until the dialogue begins.
An excellent example     On: 2004-12-07

of how great acting can surpass the film itself. Watch this for the acting, which is truly dazzling, the photography, which is amazing, or the direction, which is sharp. Otherwise, the dialogue to WAY too stagy in too many parts, and the plot itself has more than a few uninteresting slowdowns. One of those films that seems FAR longer than it is.
I haven't seen it but...     On: 2004-11-13

The West Wings POTUS Bartlet & Toby quote from the film in a season three episode:
"Geoffrey says, You fool! As if it matters how a man falls down. And Richard says, When the falls all thats left, it matters a great deal."
Its Bartlets favourite movie - recommendation enough for me.
Great dialogues     On: 2004-10-20

This movies deserves its great reviews. The story, I found, is somewhat difficult to follow at times and you have to watch it several times to appreciate all that goes on. And I did watch it three times in a row. Katherine Hepburn is inimitable as the queen. She delivers her lines with such acuteness. The pacing of the dialogues is really faultless and what the movie lacks for in live action, it more than makes up in dialogue and humour. And who needs swordfights anyway if there is so much action to be found in a well written dialogue? There are not enough movies made this way nowadays. Very much recommended.
When the stars align     On: 2004-10-16

Perfect is the word that best describes this film. Lead actors, direction, dialog, musical score, supporting performances all converge to make a glorious film. Henry and Eleanor are two of the most fascinating people in history. OToole and Hepburn bring them to life in a manner recognizable to anyone who cares to watch. Henry and Eleanor are the moon and sun and the supporting players revolve around them. These are two powerful people who started their relationship in a blaze of passion. Henry was a young Duke who wanted it all -- a kingship and the French Queen Eleanor.The older Eleanor already had a king and the richest duchy in Europe but she wanted Henry -- their adultery and the subsequent divorce and war made it all possible. They ruled together and apart and ultimately they turned on one another and did terrible things to each other. BUT after all of the venom, backstabbing, etc. at the end there is the fundamental truth that Henry and Eleanor love one another but so much has happened to them, they cannot live together because they cannot trust one another. Hepburn and OToole make you believe them when they are trying to verbally destroy one another and, in their tender moments, make you feel the love that is still there. Kate won the Oscar for this performance which is one of her finest. She is regal, beautiful, intelligent, domineering, scheming, and alone -- the personification of Eleanor. OToole is strong, cunning, wicked, and resourceful. You can believe that this man could have been bold enough to commit adultery with the Queen of France just as you can believe that this woman would have risked possible execution to consummate their passion. You believe that love and hate are two sides of the same coin depending on the circumstances. In this film, the coin spins as the circumstances change. This was Katharine Hepburns first film role after the death of the love of her life Spencer Tracy, I think she brought the knowledge of great love and loss to this role and in doing so created an indelible performance that everyone else in the cast rose to meet.
Ye Olde Dysfunctional Family Xmas     On: 2004-10-15

A brainy and brash Medieval talkfest that will likely disappoint Society For Creative Ananchronism types for its paucity of swordplay and severed limbs, but entertain any others who apply. Peter OToole plays Englands Henry II like a true Christmas ham, and together with his acid-tongued Queen Eleanor (Katherine Hepburn), proceeds to (verbally) carve up the family for holiday dinner. The film is absolutely electric whenever OToole and Hepburn share a scene. They tear into each other like "Whos Afraid Of Virginia Woolf"s George and Martha transplanted to a 12th-century English castle. Oh, and the "boys" are home for the holdiays, too, and "My Three Sons" they aint! Led by Anthony Hopkins militaristic Richard, the brothers plot, intrigue and swap inner-family alliances several times before the yams are even done. Look for a very young Timothy Dalton as Phillip of France, who has some nasty tricks up his Christmas stocking as well. Hepburn walked away with the 1968 Best Actress Oscar for her performance, and its not hard to see why, with made-to-order one-liners like "Well now, what SHALL we hang first, the holly...or each other?" Anyone who relishes a well-turned phrase or a well-aimed barb will be entertained.
Indescribable... The Best of Films. (and I'm fifteen!)     On: 2004-08-13

I was so thrilled to see that A Lion in Winter received top viewer remarks. If any movie deserves unfaltering adoration, this one does! Ive seen it so many times I can practically recite the dialogue, but it is still riveting. If I can influence just one person to see this movie, Ill be happy.

For history addicts like myself, this movie is satisfying beyond words. Every brief mention, every conversation, and every dredged up life story is totally dead-on. Regardless of your feelings toward period-films, A Lion in Winter is worth every second you devote to its viewing. (This movie is NOT a dried-up classic. Its as alive as any modern-day melodrama- more so.)

Katharine Hepburn IS Eleanor of Aquitaine. And Peter OToole is absolutely amazing as Henry II. I loved the depiction of all three sons, although I was less than fond of Alais. (The character, not the actress.) Geoffrey, in particular, stood out- I cant imagine why the actor appeared in so few productions. And of course, Phillip of France was a great addition to the plot. Timothy Dalton is perfect for any number of historical roles (such as Llewelyn Fawr).

Finally, the most amazing element of the movie is the dialogue. These characters actually come to life, in more ways than youd think possible. This is historys most dysfunctional family, after all.

And if youre looking for a brief explanatory note, here goes: Henry II, King of England, celebrates Christmas in Normandy with his wife and sons, while battling out the succession with all three of them- plot twists ensue. The year is 1183, and Queen Eleanor, Duchess of Aquitaine and former Queen of France has been temporarily released from her castle-prison. This impetuous, intelligent, and plainly notorious Queen was first imprisoned ten years earlier... why? For plotting rebellion while aiding and abetting her treacherous young sons. Henry also has to deal with a seventeen-year-old king of France- the surprisingly adept and politically savvy Phillip I. And while all three sons clamor for the throne, Henry practices his gifts for stalling and posturing, promising the world to youngest son John while refusing to give up so much as an acre of his empire. Eleanor throws herself whole-heartedly into the race, willing to do anything to see her favorite son Richard crowned.

Anything, that is, except endanger the husband she loathes but still loves.
dysfunction at its finest     On: 2004-08-08

I cannot say enough good things about this film. Hepburn and OToole give amazing performances. The dialogue is brilliant-- witty and creative. There are so many scenes which are at once heart-wrenching and hilarious. Definitely worthy of multiple viewings. My only complaint would be some of the verbal exchanges last a bit too long and can be exhaustive, but that doesnt at all take away from beauty of this film. I love the tongue-in-cheek manner in which it pokes fun of medieval stereotypes and how it even slips in a few anachronisms. I recommend it without reserve to anyone interested in politics, royalty, history, or family drama-- which should be just about everyone.
Save Your Marriage--See This Movie     On: 2004-07-12

I think it is perfectly appropriate to personalize great works of art such as this film. By this I mean that this film has practical implications and application. Do not judge this film simply on its artistic merits, but use it as a mirror on your own life, and indeed on societys. By that standard, this film is not just a cautionary tale, a fascinating character study, an exciting slice of life, or an exhilarating arc of performance, but a thing with actual usefulness.

Who cannot relate to the pathologies on display here? Who could deny that most families have their own version of the "dramas" discussed in this timeless film? Who hasnt had a Christmas at one point or another where "drama" overtook the phony and forced familial facade?

The next time you get into a fight with a loved one, take the time to see how bad it can get and watch and discuss this movie. It is a rare thing when art rises to such stature, and this film is a tour de force of the dramatic arts.


Not an everyday Christmas tale...     On: 2004-07-01

Therell be pork in the treetops come morning!
Thus shouts Queen Eleanor of Acquitaine to King Henry II, in a shouting match that never ends during the course of the fabulous film. An inventive historical drama recounting the lives of several of medieval Europes most colourful characters, I can scarce begin to list the number of lines that stand out from the banter.

`The Lion in Winter has long been one of my favourite films. I never tire of watching it, and love to find opportunities to incorporate lines from the film into my own `witty banter as appropriate. Peter OToole and Katherine Hepburn, in performances nearly unequalled by either in other works, provide the main action, while the very young actors Anthony Hopkins and Timothy Dalton help fill out the cast in their debut roles (Nigel Terry, later to play King Arthur in Excalibur, also plays one of the kings sons). Done in period costume and set (the King emerging from his castle, not on a red carpet, but rather striding among the chickens scrambling to escape the regal steps), there is an air of realism to the visual production that is rarely achieved in more stately presentations of lofty history. There are interesting asides, not the least of which is that King Henry seems make reference to being a bisexual -- a very daring thing in the 1960s, as well as the rumoured love affair between Richard (Richard the Lionhearted) and the King of France. Nominated for seven Academy Awards, it won three, including best screenplay -- no wonder so many delightfully witty, pithy lines come from this film.

The real history of Henry and Eleanor provides the backdrop here. Henry kept Eleanor, one of the most desirable women (apparently in form as well as property) in Europe, a virtual prisoner during much of the later part of his reign. After his eldest son Henry died (an heir crowned in the lifetime of Henry II, a rare thing among monarchs, done in part because of the church-state problems dating back to Thomas Becket, alluded to very briefly in the dialogue of the film), Henry needs a new successor. Contrary to popular belief, the succession does not automatically proceed down the ranks of the eldest children (this would arise as an issue again during Tudor times, when there was first the attempt to skip over Mary and Elizabeth in favour of Lady Jane Grey; then later, the Stuart claim comes from their having been skipped over previously, by some definitions).

Of course, Richard (Anthony Hopkins) expects to be the heir - next in line, he is also the best soldier and general. Henry (for some unknown reason) prefers John (Nigel Terry), the youngest. Geoffrey (John Castle) is all but forgotten - history will have him die prior to Henry in any event, but he has the poignant line that speaks of Geoffreys forgotten place in history. `No one ever mentions crown and thinks of Geoff, why is that?

The family has been brought together for Christmas in Chinon. This is a family best left apart, with great distances between them, as the sparks fly. All of the action here takes place in the course of two days at most and in the end, nothing is really resolved here. Plots keep spinning and turning, more Byzantine than the Byzantines could ever hope to be, without any real conclusion. I guess politics never change after all.

The sets are great, realistic, filmed in castle settings in Ireland, Britain and France. Nice touches include the juxtaposition of the commonplace with the royal - unlike todays royal cocoon, there wasnt much distance between the lordly types and the regular folk. The costuming is likewise well-done, understated but entirely appropriate.

However, this is a film of dialogue, based on the play by James Goldman (who also did the screenplay). The plots and twists are non-stop, rather like a chess game conducted with real careers and acerbic, witty commentary designed both for pleasure and pain as the situation progresses. In the end, there is a merry stalemate, and Eleanor returns to her confinement, and one assumes history proceeds apace. One almost forgets this is supposed to be a Christmas gathering!

At several points in the activity, the characters confess exhaustion and faint from the efforts of continually trying to outflank each other. Yet the politics, here both national and family in character, goes on.

A fantastic film, one that holds up well with age.


Wholesome family entertainment     On: 2004-06-29

Just kidding. This is the ultimate depiction of a deeply and truely dysfunctional family. But, what a tale it is. This kind of film is timeless. I recently watched the Showtime Original version (Patrick Stewart & Glenn Close), and found it just as captivating. I favor this 1968 version better; nobody out does OToole and Hepburn. Peter OToole is seathingly into his role as Henry. Even better is Katherine Hepburn as Eleanor (a role I consider to be tailer-made for her). My favorite understatement in motion picture history is stated by her. "What family doesnt have its ups and downs." The scene in which this quote appears makes the statement totally true. It is such a pity that she had to share her third Academy Award victory with Miss Diva Streisand for FUNNY GIRL. The supporting cast are remarkably on mark. Especially, Anthony Hopkins and Timothy Dalton, both making their film debut in THE LION IN WINTER. If you havent seen this movie, please do. It is worth the time!!!
A Domestic Drama of Epic Proportions     On: 2004-05-27

It has been many years since I first viewed this film. I was a teenager, an English lit major and dazzled by the verbal pyrotechnics. I still keenly recall Eleanors evocative and erotic lines about first meeting Henry; "He had a mind like Aristotle and a form like mortal sin...we shattered the commandments upon the spot!" Whew! Eleanor, both historically and fictionally was either the last of the grand pagan matriarchs, or the first truly modern woman. The screenwriter understood she was the equal of her husband, King Henry, and their remarkable marriage/alliance was a decades long tug of war for supremacy. It is the sunset of their lives we find them in this film. They treat their own adult children as pawns in their ceaseless struggle for power. Henry flaunts his young mistress, while Eleanor wields her wealth, erotic past, and influence over her eldest son. The movie is seamless; and immensely refreshing in that a piece about Henry II doesnt focus on Beckett. Hes mentioned, of course, but only as a sidebar. Hepburn if memory serves was actually older than OToole but that mere physical fact only serves to reinforce the illusion of a clash between titans. After all, Eleanor too was older than Henry. Of the supporting cast I can think of no weak links. Anthony Hopkins as the sexually confused Richard the Lionheart adequately presages the remarkable career to follow. Again, I highly recommend this film. Ive often mused that if Oscar Wilde had ventured to write a historical drama the results may have been similar to The Lion In Winter. I can offer no higher praise.
Forget the Lion, How 'Bout that Lioness!!     On: 2004-03-02

I think that most people who have seen this movie agree that its fantastic. Witty, wicked, wordy and visually beautiful "The Lion In Winter" took my breath away. There is one thing that many people might disagree with me about. I dont think that Henry (OToole) and Eleanor (Hepburn) are evenly matched. I think that Queen Eleanor aways had the upper hand and her loving husband responded by exiling her. I think that Queen Eleanor was smarter than her husband, he knew it & resented it. There was a great passionate love between these two that flamed out (at least on the male side).
In her youth, Eleanor of Aquitaine was considered the most beautiful woman in the world, and she was educated at the most sophisticated court in the world, also she was loaded. When she married Henry, he was just a Duke, and she had been Queen of France, a bit of a letdown to say the least.
I cant help but think that Henry always resented his wifes wealth & superior station, but she loved him anyway.
Two of the saddest scenes in this movie involve Eleanor. One is while putting on a brave face, she demands that Henry kiss young Alice in front of her. Henry, never missing an opportuinity to hurt the Missus, gleefully obliges. Eleanor almost crumbles before your eyes, its a very moving & powerful scene. The other is when Eleanor is alone in her room & she picks up her looking glass and sees an old woman looking back; her silence speaks a thousand words.
OToole makes a wonderful Henry, selfish, cruel and ever inward turning without posessing the least amount of insight or self awareness.
This is a fabulous movie, and should not be missed.
How to screw up your marriage...     On: 2004-02-02

I am not going to retread over all that the other reviewers have said--that the acting and dialogue in this movie is among the best ever in any movie. My only new thing to add is that at the heart of the dysfunctional family is one of the most fascinating married couples in any movie, ever. Essentially, this movie is not about three men vying for the throne; it is about a marriage and its slow failure--it is a character study. And an extremely intriguing one made most effective by the excellent acting and scathing dialogue. It could be that the movie is a bit long, but its extremely enjoyable nevertheless. And there are lots of quotable lines thatll make you sound worldly and knowledgeable.
Henry and Eleanor Picnicing on Each Other...     On: 2004-01-17

When Katharine Hepburn utters the line "Theres going to be a Christmas Court" you can see the wheels start grinding in her head. She thanks Henry for letting her out of jail for the festivities. Her children bicker and snipe at each other throughout the holiday. Henry kisses